Teacher Discussion Forum for Math 30-1

Does this question still fit the curriculum

 
 
Picture of Ken  Hovey
Does this question still fit the curriculum
by Ken Hovey - Tuesday, 9 October 2012, 4:19 PM
 

or does the irrational factors take it ourside the curriculum.

 

See the attachement as this web format does not like Mathtype

Picture of Jacqueline Fern
Re: Does this question still fit the curriculum
by Jacqueline Fern - Tuesday, 9 October 2012, 8:22 PM
 

From CARC Session with Alberta Education Sept. 2012 ... they said

students are to be able to recognize from a graph that no real roots exist, but will not be expected to calculate them

Picture of Ken  Hovey
Re: Does this question still fit the curriculum
by Ken Hovey - Wednesday, 10 October 2012, 11:02 AM
 

I agree but these are real roots just not rational. 

The curriculum says integer coefficients for polynomials but would be doing a difference of squares factoring giving irrational roots be beyond what we would expect of these students?

Picture of Stephanie MacKay
Re: Does this question still fit the curriculum
by Stephanie MacKay - Thursday, 11 October 2012, 7:58 PM
 

Jenny Kim from Alberta Education sent this reply:

I've talked to my cohorts in curriculum as well, and we all agree that this question would be fine. As long as you are dividing by a factor of the form (x - a), where a is an integer, which is the case for this example, the remaining quadratic factors do not need to be of the form (x - a).